
The following criteria and questions can help you to judge the value of a source.
Instructions: Use the book you have found on our class topic in the Mohammed VI Library. Answer the following questions in order to assess the credibility of your chosen source; you may find the answers by checking through the appropriate parts of the book, or you may need to do some additional research:
1. First, write the full reference here:
My book reference is America’s Food “what you don’t know about what you eat” by Harvey Blatt, ISBN 978-0-262-02652-9.
2. Evaluate Authority: Who is the author of this text? Do they have a degree or other expertise that qualifies them to write on the subject? What else has the author published?
“Harvey Blatt is the author of America's Environmental Report Card: Are We Making the Grade? (MIT Press). He taught geology at the University of Houston and the University of Oklahoma for many years and is now Professor of Geology at the Institute of Earth Sciences at Hebrew University of Jerusalem.” MIT Press.
http://mitpress.mit.edu/catalog/author/default.asp?aid=226663. Evaluate Affiliation: What institution (company, organization, university, etc.) published this book? Is it a commercial or non-profit publisher? What else does the institution publish? Would the author's affiliation with this publisher bias their work?
The MIT press which is Massachusetts Institute of Technology. “The MIT Press is the only university press in the United States whose list is based in science and technology.” However, they published beyond science and engineering. They published “about 200 new books a year and over 40 journals.” “They are a major publishing presence in fields as diverse as architecture, social theory, economics, cognitive science, and computational science, and we have a long-term commitment to both design excellence and the efficient and creative use of new technologies.” their aim is to create books and journals that are “challenging, creative, attractive, and yet affordable to individual readers.”
http://mitpress.mit.edu/mitpress/history/default.asp4. Evaluate Currency: When was the book published and/or last updated? Will you use it for current information or for historical context?
2008, however this book has a comparison between before the 20th century where agriculture was organic and now where it is made by chemicals.
5. Evaluate Audience: Who is the intended audience (students, educators, the general public, experts) for the book? Is it written for someone with a small or large amount of knowledge on the subject?
It is written for everybody even if the title is America’s food since in all over the world farms use chemicals; therefore, I found the book very reflective what’s going on Morocco’s farms.
6. Evaluate Purpose: What appears to be the purpose for the book? Is it to inform, persuade, entertain, report, or refute?
The book is informing the reader about the food that everybody buys in the supermarket and report some facts and survey to better show the issue.
7. Evaluate Sources: Where did the author get their information? Is there a bibliography? Are there footnotes? Does the author refer to primary or secondary material?
The author took a lot of information from several books and the bibliography has more than 4 pages.
8. Conclusion: Now that you have assessed your book in more detail, do you still think it is useful? Explain why or why not. If you do intend to use it, name the chapters or sections that you think will be most useful for your topic.
The book that I pick from the library as a hunt and help for my project is very helpful and useful even before using and answering those questions. In fact, it is helpful even in my personal life since after reading this book and even while reading it I’ll figure out what I eat specially that the book refer to chemicals and some fertilizers that farmers are using to grow fast the vegetables or more worse to grow chickens. Also, the book shows as where some diseases are since those chemicals can kill people after a period of time.